← All posts
Blog

THE ACTING TRAP

16 November 2026 · 7 min read

Are You Being Developed or Just Keeping the Chair Warm?

You're not getting promoted. You're "acting". And sometimes, that distinction matters more than you think.

There is something particularly appealing about being asked to step into a more senior position.

It is recognition. It is an opportunity to demonstrate your capabilities, gain experience and show management that you are ready for the next step in your career.

You are entrusted with greater responsibility. You attend meetings you previously would not have attended. You make decisions that carry greater consequences. You manage people, budgets and operations that were previously outside your scope.

For many employees, an acting appointment is the first real opportunity to prove that they are capable of operating at the next level.

And there is absolutely nothing wrong with that.

But there is another side to the story.

What happens when the temporary appointment becomes permanent in everything except name?

What happens when three months becomes six, six becomes nine, and the explanation remains the same?

"We're still looking."

Welcome to what I call the acting trap.

1. The opportunity: A foot in the door

Let's be fair. Acting appointments serve a legitimate purpose.

Organisations need to maintain continuity when senior employees resign, take extended leave, are transferred or when vacancies arise.

An acting appointment can be an excellent development opportunity.

It allows an employee to:

  • Gain practical management experience.
  • Develop leadership and decision-making skills.
  • Increase their visibility within the organisation.
  • Demonstrate their ability to manage greater responsibility.
  • Build confidence and credibility.

It can also give an employer the opportunity to assess whether an employee is genuinely suited to a more senior position.

In the right circumstances, everyone benefits.

The problem isn't the acting appointment itself.

The problem starts when the arrangement becomes open-ended, unclear or convenient for one party at the expense of the other.

2. When temporary starts becoming permanent

Imagine this scenario.

You are appointed to act as a departmental manager for three months while the organisation finalises its recruitment process.

You accept.

You put in the extra hours. You take responsibility for the department. You deal with the difficult decisions and carry the accountability that comes with the position.

Three months later, management asks you to continue.

There are delays in the recruitment process.

Six months later, you are still acting.

The explanation?

"We're still looking."

Nine months later, you are still doing the job.

At this point, a reasonable question arises:

Is this still a development opportunity, or has the organisation simply found a convenient way to fill a vacancy without making a permanent appointment?

There is an important distinction between giving someone an opportunity to develop and relying on that person to perform a higher-level role indefinitely without providing clarity about their future.

An acting appointment should not become a substitute for proper workforce planning.

3. The responsibility increases. Does the recognition?

One of the most frustrating aspects of an acting appointment is the imbalance that can develop between responsibility and recognition.

Consider what may change when you step into a senior position:

  • Bigger decisions.
  • Bigger budgets.
  • Greater accountability.
  • More complex employee relations issues.
  • Increased pressure from management.
  • Responsibility for the performance of an entire department.

Yet your substantive position, remuneration and employment status may remain unchanged, apart from any applicable acting allowance.

The employee is effectively carrying the weight of a more senior position while remaining uncertain about whether the organisation sees them as a genuine candidate for permanent appointment.

This is where the arrangement deserves closer scrutiny.

An employee should understand what additional authority accompanies the appointment, what compensation applies and what happens if the acting arrangement is extended.

Responsibility without clarity is a recipe for frustration.

4. The acting allowance: Don't overlook the fine print

An acting allowance can be an important part of the arrangement.

However, employees should not assume that every acting appointment automatically carries an allowance, or that the allowance will continue indefinitely.

The applicable employment contract, collective agreement, organisational policy and established workplace practice may all be relevant.

Questions worth asking include:

  • Is an acting allowance payable?
  • How is it calculated?
  • When does payment commence?
  • What happens if the acting appointment is extended?
  • Under what circumstances can the allowance be withdrawn?
  • Does the allowance stop when the employee returns to their substantive position?

There is also an important legal consideration here.

Section 186(2)(a) of the Labour Relations Act recognises unfair conduct relating to promotion and the provision of benefits as potential unfair labour practices.

In the right circumstances, a dispute concerning an acting allowance may fall within this framework.

An acting allowance is not necessarily just a discretionary favour that an employer can withdraw without considering the applicable policy, practice and legal position.

The details matter.

5. The uncomfortable truth: Acting does not guarantee promotion

This is probably the most important point employees need to understand.

Being appointed to act in a position does not automatically entitle you to permanent appointment.

You may be performing the role exceptionally well. You may have more institutional knowledge than the other candidates. You may even be the most experienced person in the department.

But that does not necessarily mean the organisation is obliged to appoint you permanently.

The Labour Relations Act does, however, provide protection against unfair conduct relating to promotion.

An employee who believes that an employer has acted unfairly in a promotion process may, depending on the circumstances, have grounds to pursue an unfair labour practice dispute.

The distinction is important:

You do not automatically have a right to the promotion. You do have a right to fair treatment in the promotion process.

An employer should therefore ensure that recruitment and selection decisions are made fairly, consistently and in accordance with applicable policies and procedures.

Equally, employees should not confuse an acting appointment with a promise of permanent employment in the higher position.

Manage your expectations, but also know your rights.

6. The benefits are real. Don't dismiss them.

It would be unfair to suggest that acting appointments are inherently exploitative.

They can be enormously beneficial.

Experience. Exposure. Confidence. Skills. Visibility.

These are valuable career assets.

Even if the permanent appointment ultimately goes to someone else, the experience gained may strengthen your professional profile and improve your prospects elsewhere.

The key is understanding what you are gaining and what you are giving up.

If the arrangement is genuinely developmental, with clear objectives, appropriate support and a reasonable timeframe, it can be an excellent opportunity.

If it becomes an indefinite arrangement with no meaningful feedback, no clarity and no transparent recruitment process, it may be time to reconsider the value of the opportunity.

7. Six questions to ask before accepting an acting appointment

Before stepping into a more senior role, consider asking management the following:

1. How long will the acting appointment last?

Establish a proposed start and end date. If an extension is required, ask how that decision will be communicated.

2. Is the permanent position going to be advertised?

Understand whether the organisation intends to conduct a formal recruitment process and what the anticipated timeline is.

3. What are the requirements for permanent appointment?

Make sure you understand the qualifications, experience and competencies required for the position.

4. Will I be considered for the permanent position?

An acting appointment should not be mistaken for automatic shortlisting or preferential treatment. Establish what the actual recruitment process will be.

5. What additional authority and responsibilities will I receive?

You cannot reasonably be expected to carry accountability for decisions without understanding the authority delegated to you.

6. What happens to my remuneration and acting allowance?

Get clarity on the financial implications, including what happens if the appointment is extended or terminated.

Most importantly, get the arrangement documented.

A written agreement helps manage expectations and reduces the likelihood of misunderstandings later.

8. Employers have responsibilities too

Employers should not view acting appointments simply as an administrative solution to an operational problem.

They should consider the implications for the employee, the organisation and the wider workplace.

A well-managed acting appointment should have:

  • A clearly defined purpose.
  • A reasonable duration.
  • Documented responsibilities and delegated authority.
  • Clarity regarding remuneration and allowances.
  • Appropriate performance feedback.
  • A transparent recruitment and selection process where a permanent vacancy exists.

It is also worth remembering that repeatedly extending an acting appointment without explaining the reasons can create frustration, damage trust and potentially expose the organisation to employment disputes.

The objective should be to create an arrangement that benefits both parties.

Not one that simply keeps the department functioning at someone else's expense.

9. So, should you accept an acting appointment?

My answer?

Yes, potentially.

But don't accept it blindly.

An acting appointment can be a stepping stone to something bigger. It can accelerate your development and give you experience that you might otherwise wait years to acquire.

But ambition should not come at the expense of clarity.

Understand the arrangement. Establish the expectations. Clarify the financial implications. Find out what the permanent recruitment process looks like.

And remember that you are allowed to ask questions before accepting additional responsibility.

Sometimes, stepping up is exactly what you need to do.

Other times, you need to understand what you're stepping into.

STEP UP. BUT KNOW WHAT YOU'RE STEPPING INTO.

A final word from Labour Law Sherpa

Acting appointments are not inherently unfair, nor are they automatically a pathway to promotion.

The difference often lies in how the arrangement is structured, communicated and managed.

For employees, the lesson is to understand the opportunity before accepting the responsibility.

For employers, the lesson is to ensure that temporary arrangements remain fair, transparent and properly managed.

Because keeping the chair warm is one thing.

Expecting someone to carry the weight of the position indefinitely is quite another.

Need clarity on an acting appointment, promotion dispute or acting allowance?

Labour Law Sherpa helps employers and employees navigate the complexities of South African labour law.

Don't wait until a temporary arrangement becomes a permanent problem.

Call the Sherpa before you lose your footing.